Innerarity Island Properties for Sale

Our website features the best Innerarity Island real estate search for homes, condo, land and foreclosure properties available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Avg. No of Beds

Avg. No of Baths

Avg. Living Ft²

Avg. Listing Price

Cost per ft²

Days on Market

Innerarity Island Popular Searches

Innerarity Island Properties by Price

Innerarity Island Properties by # of Bedroom(s)

Innerarity Island Properties by # of Bathroom(s)

Curious about what’s happening in the Innerarity Island real estate market? Sign up for a Innerarity Island Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Innerarity Island Properties for Sale

$629,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 653546 MLS

A Must See! This customized 'owner built and occupied' home on Innerarity Island is definitely one to put on your search list to see first. The owner has taken the guess work out of the modern comforts of home-life when designing this home. Heavy front doors, 165 mph hurricane proof windows, metal roof, MiraTech composite wood, moisture, rot and termite resistant exterior 50 yr warranty, fully extra insulated attic keeping electric bill mid $200 year round, hardwood floors. Spacious kitchen with all stainless steel appliances, LG large refrigerator with front glass double open door with light, allowing a quick view or only opening the front part to grab a drink. A built in pot filler faucet over large gas stove, farmer style sink built in island, all brass fixtures, convection mircrowave and stove, 2 spice cabinets both sides of the stove, built in mixer cabinet, wide flat pan cabinet w/ separating racks above the oven, designed tile stove back splash with clear covers on sides to stay clean. Large centered island with heavy, thick high-end marble top. Formal dining area, laundry room near back of house, oversized stainless steel washer and dryer, and 1/2 bathroom. The master bathroom contains glass door, tiled large shower, a white claw foot tub w/ brass side fixtures, separate full vanity sinks on each side of the bathroom, one with built in makeup area w/ chair and lots of drawers and cabinet space around both. Master bedroom closet with built in shoe wall, extra shelving, top and bottom clothes racks. Private back yard wood fence with natural woods behind, 15 x 8 screen back porch. Far set back from road, 48 ft front porch across width of home, grassy front yard, 120 sq ft yard building.Disclosure: Buyer to verify all measurements.

16410 Innerarity Pt Rd, Pensacola

$75,000

653476 MLS

Own a piece of the Island ! Nice location at the end of Innerarity Point Island. A vacant residential lot on one of the only two cul-de-sacs on this last road on the island to build your dream home ! This lot is located in a unique, quiet family waterfront community with much to see and do. A private waterfront community park near by for picnics, family gatherings, pickle-ball, festivals, cook-outs, etc. Close to Perdido Key beaches, boat launch, minutes from back entrance of Pensacola Naval Air Station, local restaurants, Perdido Bay at the end of the cul-de-sac, nice for walking or driving around on your golf cart enjoying the view. Drive through the neighborhood and take a look for yourself as you imagine this as your next homesite !

16601 Blue Heron Cir, Pensacola

$799,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 653320 MLS

You'll love this sublime Innerarity Island Pool Home! This immaculate EarthCents Certified, 2-story, 3 bedroom, 2½ bath home exudes modern elegance. The expansive front porch incorporates a welcoming hand-crafted double exterior door that invites you to step into 2,445 square feet of pristine style. This captivating home features a spacious open floor plan with a first floor master suite, marble countertops throughout, engineered hardwood floors, and a chef’s kitchen with stainless steel Kitchenaid appliances and a 6-burner gas stove, perfect for entertaining and socializing with friends and family. Additional features include PGT impact rated windows, icynene spray foam insulation in the roof, 2x6 construction, and (2) 16-seer air conditioning units wired for a portable generator. The backyard paradise has an in ground gunite pool with a new pump that features a 3-year warranty, gas hookup for family BBQs and provides plenty of shade with mature oak trees and green space views. The 3-car garage sanctuary boasts a roomy 1,200 square foot space perfect for cars, trucks, boats and motorcycles. The hot tub powered by dedicated 240V circuit so it can quickly heat up. Open house scheduled for November 9th. No showings prior to the open house.

5781 Red Cedar St, Pensacola

$943,800

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 652541 MLS

Welcome to Your Dream Coastal Retreat on Innerarity Island! Nestled in the exclusive gated community of Innerarity Island, this stunning two-story, four-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bathroom home blends luxury, comfort, and coastal living. With extensive renovations and a VA assumable mortgage, this home is truly one-of-a-kind. A charming front porch spans the width of the house, perfect for relaxing and enjoying the breeze. Inside, a spacious living room features custom cabinetry and a striking 60" linear fireplace framed with quarried stone. Custom wooden shutters throughout the home add charm and privacy. The open-concept kitchen and dining area boasts a butcher block island, Frigidaire Professional appliances, and Rhino White Calcite countertops. The farmhouse sink faces windows opening to the backyard, ensuring you never miss the poolside action. The primary bedroom is on the main floor, offering two walk-in closets and a renovated ensuite bathroom with Carrara Quartz countertops, heated floors, a steam shower, 60" freestanding tub, and heated towel rack. A second main-level bedroom, overlooking the front porch, includes a large walk-in closet, ideal for guests or family. The redesigned laundry room, with handcrafted cabinetry and built-in benches, leads to your outdoor paradise. A 20,000-gallon saltwater pool with a sunbathing ledge and soothing bubblers awaits, while a cascading waterfall from the hot tub adds to the tranquility. The newly installed paver patio and landscaped, fenced yard make it perfect for outdoor entertaining. The home also includes a hardwired electric vehicle charging station. Upstairs, you'll find two additional bedrooms, a versatile office or study, and a bonus room ideal as a playroom or media space. Don’t miss the opportunity to own this meticulously crafted retreat in one of Pensacola’s most desirable island communities.

16240 Innerarity Pt Rd, Pensacola

$1,200,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 651045 MLS

One-of-a-kind, craftsman-style coastal home on sought after Innerarity Island. This visually stunning, four-bedroom home integrates 16' ceilings; cypress posts, beams, and floating shelving; upgraded millwork; and a second floor Carriage house that includes a full kitchen, full bath, four season sun room, bedroom/office, and separate staired entryway. The open first floor plan provides plenty of space for entertaining; abundant lighting; a walk-in pantry and master closet both furnished with floor to ceiling shelving and pullouts; and sliding door framed access to a spacious, lanai-enclosed deck with a low-maintenance, heated, salt pool with built-in spa, travertine decking, remote controlled lanai shades, and an outdoor kitchen, replete with a luxury 48" DCS grill, matching vent hood, separate two-burner griddle, and enclosed refrigerator. Built with Structurally Integrated Panels and Florida Hurricane-rated windows throughout, this house employs one of the strongest, most energy efficient construction methods available. Leveraging energy-saving LED lighting and designer Maestro dimmer switches, energy usage is almost 1/2 that of the average home. Extending the interior attention to detail, the house incorporates a mini-split air conditioned three-car garage, custom stone driveways, low maintenance landscaping, Arlo full-perimeter security monitoring system, separate sewer-fee-saving pool water and irrigation system metering, whole house gas-fueled generator, and neatly designed outdoor utility space that keeps your living and entertainment areas clean and quiet.

16600 Innerarity Pt Rd, Pensacola

$725,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 650847 MLS

Here is your chance to live on an island in paradise! Come see this beautiful pool home with a waterview on Innerarity Island! Boasting great curb appeal with its tropical landscaping, this home sits high and dry with no history of flooding! When you step in side you will be greeted with a large open living room as well as a large dining room to the left. The living room features authentic real wood flooring, tall ceilings and windows giving you plenty of natural light. The living room leads to the spacious kitchen complete with stainless appliances, tile floors, granite countertops, real wood cabinets and more! There is a small sun porch located off the kitchen as well! The master suite is located on the ground floor opposite of the kitchen. It is a large room with a spacious bathroom complete with a garden tub, separate stand up shower, his and hers vanities and closets. The upstairs features three additional bedrooms with a jack and jill style bathroom separating two of the guest rooms. The salt water pool is perfect for enjoying the Florida lifestyle while overlooking Perdido Bay in your very own backyard! There is also a greenbelt behind the home where you can access Perdido Bay with your paddleboards, kayaks or whatever your heart desires! The home comes with a lot of upgrades including a three year old architectural shingle roof, brand new natural gas standby generator, brand new impact rated patio sliding door, brand new “she-shed” which can serve as a workshop or extra storage. Your tropical oasis awaits, schedule your showing today!

5586 North Shore Way, Pensacola

$175,000

650641 MLS

Enjoy Pensacola's Stunning Sunsets EVERY. SINGLE. DAY. Want to overlook Perdido Bay and enjoy the most stunning sunsets that our slice of Florida has to offer each and every evening? Then these is the lots are for you. Yes, "lots" meaning you get 2 contiguous lots which together are over a half acre. These lots face south on coveted and gated Innerarity Island located across the street from the water. Here, you will be able to build the house of your dreams with second-floor water views...

5606 Innerarity Cir, Pensacola

$75,000

649789 MLS

Wooded Corner Lot on Innerarity Island offers the ideal location for your dream home within a tranquil gated community. Notably, this lot is in Flood Zone X, meaning no flood insurance is required. The HOA annual dues are $250, covering the maintenance of common areas, private roads, the park, and the security gate. This beautiful lot is located in a prime area on the island, surrounded by well-maintained homes and just steps away from the waterfront community park. The island's natural scenery, indigenous wildlife, and stunning views make it a family-friendly paradise. Innerarity Island is not just a location; it's a vibrant community where the magic of nature intertwines with the warmth of its residents, offering a unique and fulfilling lifestyle. Securely gated and family-friendly, this is your opportunity to build your dream home in an exceptional setting. Here, modern living seamlessly blends with the pristine beauty of nature. The landscape serves as a sanctuary for diverse wildlife, including foxes, deer, and ospreys. At the heart of the community is a meticulously maintained park overlooking Perdido Bay. Residents gather for "Sunsets at the Park," enjoying wine and pickleball matches. Recent park upgrades include a pickleball court, a small pier, a picnic area, and an upcoming playground for children. The true charm of Innerarity Island lies in its vibrant community spirit. Engage in an active social scene with events like golf cart parades, potluck gatherings, Wine Wednesdays, and more. Come and experience the unique charm and welcoming spirit of Innerarity Island today!

5600 BLK North Shore Way, Pensacola

$599,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 646248 MLS

Welcome to your dream home in the exclusive gated community of Innerarity Island! This custom-built, four-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bathroom residence offers a luxurious and serene lifestyle. The home features a split floor plan, a spacious kitchen-living room combo, a formal dining room, a sunroom, and an oversized first-floor primary suite. The updated kitchen is a chef's delight, boasting an eat-in breakfast bar, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and ample cabinetry. Situated on over half an acre, this property provides unparalleled privacy and a sense of tranquility. Enjoy the expansive backyard from the comfort of your second-floor deck. A large two-car garage and a circular driveway offer ample parking for you and your guests. This home has been well maintained, with a new roof installed in 2023. Innerarity Island is renowned for its natural beauty, featuring nature conservation areas, a community park on the water with a pickle ball court and basketball hoop, and abundant wildlife, including foxes, deer, and various bird species. Residents of Innerarity Island are surrounded by trees, greenways, and protected nature areas. As you cross the causeway to the island, you'll feel the stress melt away, inspired by breathtaking sunsets over the water. Conveniently located near the pristine beaches of Perdido Key, Orange Beach, and Gulf Shores, and just 15 minutes from the back gate of NAS Pensacola, this home offers the perfect blend of seclusion and accessibility.

16300 Innerarity Pt Rd, Pensacola

$695,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 645200 MLS

Welcome to your exclusive island lifestyle! Beautiful house with amazing unobstructed water views! Enjoy sunsets and sunrises from your fully screened porch, gaze on deers and foxes passing by, snack on fruits and berries from your own backyard and live in peace with friendly neighbors. This meticulously maintained subdivision offers pickle ball court, picnic areas, private beaches and parks within walking distance. House was built in 2022 and a lot of upgrades were put in by the owners, like additional driveway, granite countertops, tiles, landscaping, fence, sunroom and more. House is equipped with generator, solar panels, gas line, impact windows and hurricane shutters. Inquire about 2.75% FHA assumable mortgage. Come and fall in love with the house and the neighborhood!

5304 Shore Rd, Pensacola

$1,445,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 644200 MLS

PARADISE FOUND. Gorgeous, Waterfront, residence located on sought after Innerarity Island. The front lawn is sprawling and lush with greenery and the home is perfectly situated on the large lot with breathtaking, panoramic views of Perdido Bay. The property is well maintained inside and out. The first residential level of the home is an open floor plan, letting natural light flow throughout the home. Allowing you and your guests to take in stunning sunsets from the great room. The kitchen is updated with quartz countertops, breakfast bar, gas stove for the home chef, a breakfast nook area, that is currently set up as a cozy sitting area. A spacious dining area, great room, and bar area make it the perfect place to entertain friends and family. There is an office or study room with an oversized closet, providing additional storage. Luxury Vinyl Flooring through out the main floor, allowing easy clean up behind sandy little toes. All bedrooms are located on the second level and carpeted for comfort. The master bedroom has a large walk-in closet, the master bathroom is beautifully renovated with shiplap and a quartz, double vanity. The second bathroom has been updated with a stunning, tile, walk-in shower. The master bedroom and one guest bedroom have lovely, new seating areas with french doors that over look the bay. A spacious attic with pull down stairs, has been partially finished, which is an adorable area for kids to let their imaginations run wild or could be used for additional storage or home gym. Huge oversized garage for cars and toys. The covered deck, with recessed lighting is ready for summer evening meals, coming equipped with salt water breezes. For the boater, say good-bye to public launches. Your dock, the lifts and boathouse with utilities, is just waiting for you to arrive! After a short boat ride back from the Gulf of Mexico, you can clean your catch, and enjoy a cold beverage at the boat house bar. Come make this your forever home today.

5448 North Shore Rd, Pensacola

$115,000

638726 MLS

COME SEE THIS Beautiful CORNER LOT on sought after Innerarity Island with views of Perdido Bay! This property is in a prime location on the island, low density, well maintained homes surround this area and located only steps away from the waterfront community park, providing pickle ball court, picnic area, fishing pier and green space. The island boasts of natural scenery, indigenous wild life and stunning views. The island is securely gated making it a family friendly community. Come build your dream home today! ISLAND life awaits. The neighboring lot is also being offered.

5400 BLK North Shore Rd, Pensacola

$475,000

637396 MLS

Best deal for ICW in the area! This deep water southern exposure Intercoastal front lot on a cul-de-sac with a white sand beach is located behind the gates of Innerarity Island, and is ready for your waterfront oasis. Just minutes by boat to Alabama Pass, the Gulf of Mexico, and great restaurants and bars (FloraBama, Pirate's Cove, Hub Stacy's...). The opportunity to acquire this caliber of property has become scarce. Per neighborhood covenants- the home building setback from the water can be in-line with existing neighboring homes.

5870 Red Cedar St, Pensacola

$75,000

631963 MLS

This enchanting .32-acre parcel in the Innerarity Island gated community offers the ideal location for your dream home. This parcel is situated within the tranquil haven, you'll immediately sense the seamless blend of modern living with the pristine beauty of nature. The landscape serves as a sanctuary for a diverse array of wildlife, including foxes darting through the underbrush, deer gracefully roaming the woodlands, and osprey nesting in the trees above contributing to a harmonious ecosystem. As the sun sets, the island comes alive with the melodic calls of owls and nocturnal wildlife, creating a symphony that underscores the magic of your surroundings. The community's heart is a meticulously maintained park overlooking the bay, providing stunning views of Perdido Bay. Residents gather for Sunsets at the Park, sipping wine or engaging in pickleball matches. Recent upgrades to the park include a pickleball court, small pier, picnic area and coming soon a playground for the children to play. If the amenities don't grab your attention—the amazing people of Innerarity Island make this location truly expectional. The neighbors are vibrant and welcoming, residents foster a sense of camaraderie that transforms the community into an extended family. Engage in the active social scene, where events such as Golf Cart parades, potluck gatherings, Wine Wednesdays, and carefree children playing in the cul-de-sacs create lasting connections and a sense of belonging. Innerarity Island is not just a location; it's a vibrant community where the magic of nature intertwines with the warmth of its residents, offering a unique and fulfilling lifestyle.

16502 North Shore Ln, Pensacola

Start Your Search

Copyright© 2016 by the Multiple Listing Service of the Pensacola Association of REALTORS® This information is believed to be accurate but is not guaranteed. Subject to verification by all parties. This data is copyrighted and may not be transmitted, retransmitted, copied, framed, repurposed, or altered in any way for any other site, individual and/or purpose without the express written permission of the Multiple Listing Service of the Pensacola Association of REALTORS®. Florida recognizes single and transaction agency relationships. Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. Any use of search facilities of data on this site, other than by a consumer looking to purchase real estate, is prohibited.